October 13, 2026

Pirates of the Plush Seas: Meet the Cutest Pirate Avatar Crew

Every pirate crew has a reputation. This one’s is being adorable. Pirates of the Plush Seas is a ten-Muse collection of pirate avatars — real captains’ coats, tricorns, and bandanas, worn by the softest crew ever to sail. Here is the full roster, who to start with, and how to collect the whole ship.

The Captain and the First Mate

Every set on AllTheMuse opens with a flagship pair, and the Plush Seas flagships earn it. Captain Barnacle is the Legendary of the collection (150 Muse Coins) — the captain of the cutest crew on the seven seas, treasure chest never far away, every inch the commander and none of it frightening.

First Mate Pearl, the Mythic (200 Muse Coins), keeps the gold doubloons counted and the crew in line — the calm second-in-command every great captain survives because of. Between them they set the collection’s tone: full pirate regalia, zero menace, all charm.

The Crew of Eight

Below deck are eight Common Muses at 50 coins each, and the crew roles are gloriously complete. Salty Sam works the rigging with his silver anchor. Peg-Leg Pete steers at the great wooden ship’s wheel. Parrot Pablo is the crew’s loudest voice — a parrot, worn proudly. Treasure Tessa guards the map. Anchor Andy minds the coiled rope, Coral Cora collects pink seashells between ports, Brass Finn scans the horizon through his spyglass, and Ruby — well, Ruby is the treasure, a ruby gemstone with a crew to call home.

It is a deliberately complete little world: command, navigation, lookout, treasure, and comic relief. Collectors tend to start with the crew member whose job they would steal first — an unexpectedly reliable personality test.

• Captain Barnacle — Legendary, 150 coins, the captain
• First Mate Pearl — Mythic, 200 coins, keeper of the doubloons
• Salty Sam, Peg-Leg Pete, Parrot Pablo, Treasure Tessa — Common, 50 coins each
• Anchor Andy, Coral Cora, Brass Finn, Ruby — Common, 50 coins each

How to Collect the Crew

Open the Pirates of the Plush Seas collection and collect member by member — Commons at 50 coins, the flagships at 150 and 200 — or take the collector’s route: the collection’s Avatar Bundle unlocks all ten at once for 250 Muse Coins from the Packs page, less than the flagships and two crew combined. Bundle ownership is resolved live, so any future additions to the crew would join your Vault automatically.

New collectors start with 150 bonus Muse Coins, which means the entire crew is within reach on day one. And once a pirate is yours, tap "Use in Muse" on its page to copy its prompt and paste it into Muse — the crew talks exactly like you would hope. If pirate waters are not your waters, the same flagship-pair pattern anchors every room — try the crowns of the Royals or the easels of the Art collection next.