October 13, 2026

Best Halloween Avatars: 7 Spooky Season Picks Worth Collecting

If you only collect a few Halloween avatars this October, make them count. The Spooky Season collection holds 20 plush Muse avatars, and this shortlist is our honest editorial pick of the seven that earn their shelf space first — the best overall, the best classic monsters, the cutest costumes, and the best value at 50 coins. New to collecting? Read what is a Muse avatar? first, then start at the top of this list.

Best Overall: Ghostly Boo and Pumpkin Patch

The single best Halloween avatar on AllTheMuse is Ghostly Boo, the Spooky Season Mythic at 200 Muse Coins. A ghost is the purest Halloween idea there is, and this one is all softness — a friendly little haunting you can use as a profile picture, a seasonal companion, or the face of your whole October. It is the collection’s highest rarity, and it looks the part.

Runner-up, and the best pick if your Halloween is more harvest than haunt: Pumpkin Patch, the collection’s Legendary at 150 Muse Coins. Pumpkin Patch is Halloween as a host — pumpkin-headed, proud of it, and instantly readable at any size. Between the two headliners, choose Ghostly Boo for cute-spooky and Pumpkin Patch for classic October; together they cost 350 coins, which matters for the bundle math below.

• Ghostly Boo — Spooky Season, Mythic, 200 coins — best overall
• Pumpkin Patch — Spooky Season, Legendary, 150 coins — best classic Halloween pick

Best Classic Monsters: Witchy Brew, Vampire Nights, and Frankenstein

For the costume-party classics, three Commons at 50 Muse Coins each do the heavy lifting. Witchy Brew is the best witch — hat, brew, and attitude included — and the most recognisably Halloween silhouette in the set after the pumpkin. Vampire Nights is the best pick for an elegant October profile: evening wear, fangs, and not a drop of gore.

Frankenstein rounds out the trio as the best gentle monster — a big soft giant who reads as Halloween history rather than horror. Because all three are Commons, the full classic-monster row costs 150 coins in total, the same as a single Legendary — a strong first shelf if you are collecting on welcome coins alone.

• Witchy Brew — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best witch
• Vampire Nights — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best elegant pick
• Frankenstein — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best gentle monster

Best Cute Halloween Avatars: Candy Corn and Black Cat

Not everyone wants a monster in their profile picture. Candy Corn is the best cute Halloween avatar — a Muse dressed as the candy itself, Common at 50 coins, and the sweetest possible way to signal the season. Close behind is Black Cat, also a Common at 50 coins: all superstition on the outside, house pet on the inside, and a classic pairing with any witch or pumpkin.

Add Midnight Bat, another Common at 50 coins, and the cute end of the collection is complete. These three are the picks we would hand to anyone who wants Halloween warmth without a single jump scare — and at 50 coins each, they are also the easiest yes on this list.

• Candy Corn — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best cute pick
• Black Cat — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best Halloween companion
• Midnight Bat — Spooky Season, Common, 50 coins — best night-shift pick

Best Harvest Pick: Scarecrow

The sleeper pick on this list is Scarecrow, a Common at 50 Muse Coins. Scarecrow is where Halloween meets the harvest — pumpkins, fields, and long autumn evenings — so it keeps working as a profile avatar well past October 31, long after the ghosts have gone home. If your taste runs cozy with a shiver, this is your Muse.

Scarecrow also pairs with everything else on this list: it guards Pumpkin Patch’s patch, keeps Black Cat company, and anchors a fall shelf next to the scene-setters in the full Halloween avatar ideas roster. For a broader look at the season’s shelves, browse the Muse avatars hub.

Best Value: The Spooky Season Bundle

Here is the honest maths. The two headliners on this list — Ghostly Boo at 200 coins and Pumpkin Patch at 150 — cost 350 coins together. The Spooky Season Bundle on the Packs page unlocks all 20 members at once for 250 Muse Coins, and Muses published into the collection later join bundle owners automatically. If you want more than a couple of picks, the bundle is the best value on this page by a wide margin.

Collecting a single Muse works the same either way: unlock it once with Muse Coins and it is yours forever in your Vault, with its full prompt pack, conversation style, and full-resolution artwork download. New accounts start with 150 free Muse Coins the moment you sign up — and daily rewards add 10 coins a day after that. Prices follow the rarity ladder explained in Muse Coin prices: Common 50, Rare 75, Epic 100, Legendary 150, Mythic 200. Still torn between two picks? Let the Find Your Muse quiz break the tie.