October 16, 2026

MLB Avatar Guide: Meet the MLB Top 10 Muses to Collect

An MLB avatar on AllTheMuse is not a team logo with a face — it is a finished, collectible Muse character in gameday dress. The MLB Top 10 collection, whose tagline is “Step up to the plate,” is built on a simple rule stated live on the site: the ten most prominent MLB teams of 2026, each Muse wearing its star player’s jersey and a matching team-logo hat. This guide walks the full cast of ten with rarities and coin prices verified live. New to the idea? Start with what is a Muse avatar.

Step Up to the Plate: The Two Flagships

Two flagships lead the ten. Yankees Judge is the collection’s Mythic at 200 Muse Coins, capped at 100 editions — the rarest Muse in the room, in Yankees dress. Dodgers Ohtani is the Legendary at 150 Muse Coins, capped at 250 editions, in Dodgers dress.

Collect the pair and you hold both flagship rarities in the room for 350 coins together — more than double the 150 every new account receives at signup. Every other member below is a Common at 50 coins, so the flagships are where the rarity ladder in this collection really lives.

The First Four Commons: Yelich, Acuña, Tatis and Caminero

Four Commons at 50 Muse Coins each carry the next stretch of the roster. Brewers Yelich wears the Brewers jersey and matching hat, and Braves Acuña does the same for Atlanta — two teams, two colours, the same friendly Muse underneath.

Padres Tatis brings San Diego into the room, and Rays Caminero brings Tampa Bay. At 50 coins each, these four are the easy way in: pick the team you actually follow, unlock its Muse once, and it stays in your vault.

The Second Four Commons: PCA, Anthony, Ramírez and Harper

The remaining four Commons, also 50 Muse Coins each, complete the ten the collection is named for. Cubs PCA covers Chicago and Red Sox Anthony covers Boston, each in its team’s jersey and hat.

Guardians Ramírez covers Cleveland and Phillies Harper covers Philadelphia. Together with the first four Commons, that is eight teams at 50 coins apiece — 400 coins for every Common in the room. If you follow the other gameday rooms as well, the companion NBA Top 10 guide, NFL Top 10 guide and Soccer Top 10 guide cover those rooms the same way.

Prices, the Bundle, and Where to Start

Bought one by one, the ten cost 750 Muse Coins: 200 for Yankees Judge, 150 for Dodgers Ohtani, and 50 each for the other eight. The MLB Top 10 bundle is 250 Muse Coins and unlocks every member of the room at once — membership is resolved live, so it covers the collection as it stands today. Price on AllTheMuse always follows rarity, as Muse Coin prices explained sets out: Common 50, Rare 75, Epic 100, Legendary 150, Mythic 200.

Every new account receives 150 Muse Coins at signup — enough for the whole bundle with coins to spare, or for both flagships together. If you would rather start at zero, the Free Muses room costs nothing at all, and the Find Your Muse quiz can point you at a first character in about a minute. Prefer to design a gameday character of your own instead? The Create door is where original Muses begin.

• All ten, one by one: 750 Muse Coins
• MLB Top 10 bundle: 250 Muse Coins for the whole room
• New accounts: 150 Muse Coins at signup
• Start free: the Free Muses room is 0 coins